Hilton Head’s Dim Lighting and the Rise in Nighttime Accidents

Hilton Head Island is known for its beautiful beaches, upscale resorts, and natural charm. But after sunset, that charm comes with a hidden danger. The island’s strict commitment to low lighting creates real safety risks for residents and visitors—especially on unlit roads.

They made everything easy for me! Even when I lost faith in the car accident where a drunk driver hit me, they helped me through every process. They were quick as they could be and made everything easier for me while being in the process of my move to Japan for the Navy, full time student, and planning my own wedding. I appreciated the help. Thank you!”

- Julissa Evans

I had the pleasure of allowing Mr. Leland Malchow to represent my case and I would recommend 10star rating if possible. Not only was Mr. Leland very professional and knowledgeable, he also took the time to listen to my frustrations about my situation. He offered a listening ear, as well as some kind motivational advice. Our relationship has been through business only but I would extend a hand to him and the law firm from here on out. Thank you all and God Bless."

- Chris Rowland

Chris Johnson is an exceptional attorney for car wreck cases. His expertise, clear communication, thorough preparation, and effective negotiation skills led to a favorable outcome. With compassion and support, he guided me through the process, making him highly recommended for anyone in need of a skilled legal advocate."

- Jayko Robinett

Why Is Hilton Head So Dark at Night?

The island enforces strict lighting policies to limit light pollution, preserve its low-impact design, and protect local wildlife. While these rules help maintain the night sky’s natural beauty, they’ve also made it harder to see pedestrians and road hazards in critical areas like Bluffton Parkway and South Forest Beach Drive.

“That’s not what we are. We’re trying not to be like other tourist spots where you can’t see the nighttime sky,” said Town Manager Marc Orlando, explaining the town’s resistance to brighter lighting.

But when safety is compromised, the cost can be devastating.

When Darkness Turns Deadly

Inadequate lighting has contributed to many serious and fatal accidents on Hilton Head Island. Beaufort County Sheriff P.J. Tanner has described lighting as a major factor in nighttime crashes. He supports targeted upgrades along both major roads and neighborhood streets.

One tragic example is the 2013 death of Jenny Mercer, killed in a hit-and-run while walking along South Forest Beach Drive. Her mother, Diana Mercer Imler, believes lighting could have saved her life.

“Had there been lighting there, maybe the driver would have seen her,” Imler said. “It’s so dangerous that we don’t have proper lighting, and everyone knows it.”

Leland Malchow

Attorney - Partner

Chris Johnson

Attorney - Partner

Dane Anderson

Associate Attorney

Bailey Marshall

Associate Attorney

Is It Time to Reevaluate Hilton Head’s Lighting?

Local leaders like Councilman Bill Harkins are beginning to push for changes.

“For the interest of public safety it deserves taking a look,” he said. “With new technology, lighting could focus on a prescribed area.”

Directional LED lights and shielded lamps now offer precision lighting that keeps nearby homes dark while protecting public walkways and roadways.

Lighting at intersections and crosswalks can reduce nighttime pedestrian crashes by up to 42%, according to the Federal Highway Administration.

What the Data Shows

Without proper lighting, drivers face more danger—especially in tourist-heavy seasons when many are unfamiliar with local roads. Poor visibility mixed with distracted or impaired driving increases the risk of deadly accidents.

The Federal Highway Administration confirms that smart lighting dramatically improves safety. Focused light at key locations gives drivers more time to see and react to pedestrians.

What You Can Do If You’ve Been Affected

If you or someone you love has been injured in a nighttime pedestrian accident on Hilton Head Island, you may be entitled to compensation. These cases often involve:

• Negligent drivers
• Road design failures
• Inadequate lighting

At Malchow Johnson Injury Lawyers, we handle:

• Pedestrian accident claims
• Wrongful death cases
• Injury claims involving unsafe road conditions

We offer free consultations and proudly serve families throughout Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County.

Shine a Light on Safety

Hilton Head doesn’t have to choose between charm and safety. With today’s lighting options, both are possible.

If you’re a resident or visitor, raise your voice. Ask town leaders to prioritize lighting in high-risk zones.

If your family has suffered because of the darkness, call Malchow Johnson Injury Lawyers at (706) 705-7511. We’re ready to help.

Related Videos