What to Do When an Insurance Company Calls After the Death of a Loved One

Losing a loved one is a profoundly painful experience. During this time, there’s an overwhelming amount to process — from managing personal grief and comforting family members to handling logistics like planning memorial services and dealing with financial responsibilities. Amidst this whirlwind of emotions and tasks, it’s not uncommon for an insurance company to reach out regarding policies or claims related to the deceased. While they may express their condolences, it’s important to remember that insurance companies are still businesses with their own interests in mind. When faced with this call, knowing how to proceed can be challenging yet essential to protect your family’s financial interests.

At Nimmons Malchow Johnson Injury Lawyers, we’ve had the privilege of guiding many families in Georgia and South Carolina through this difficult journey. Below, we’ll walk you through essential steps to take when an insurance company contacts you after the passing of a loved one, ensuring you’re prepared, informed, and protected.

They made everything easy for me! Even when I lost faith in the car accident where a drunk driver hit me, they helped me through every process. They were quick as they could be and made everything easier for me while being in the process of my move to Japan for the Navy, full time student, and planning my own wedding. I appreciated the help. Thank you!”

- Julissa Evans

I had the pleasure of allowing Mr. Leland Malchow to represent my case and I would recommend 10star rating if possible. Not only was Mr. Leland very professional and knowledgeable, he also took the time to listen to my frustrations about my situation. He offered a listening ear, as well as some kind motivational advice. Our relationship has been through business only but I would extend a hand to him and the law firm from here on out. Thank you all and God Bless."

- Chris Rowland

Chris Johnson is an exceptional attorney for car wreck cases. His expertise, clear communication, thorough preparation, and effective negotiation skills led to a favorable outcome. With compassion and support, he guided me through the process, making him highly recommended for anyone in need of a skilled legal advocate."

- Jayko Robinett

Take a Moment to Breathe and Process

The initial phone call from an insurance company can come as a shock. Often, they may reach out sooner than you’d expect, sometimes even before funeral arrangements are completed. When you receive this call, remember to give yourself a moment. There is no need to rush into any discussion. Politely thank the representative for their condolences, and let them know that now may not be the best time. You have every right to reschedule the conversation for a time when you feel better prepared to engage in potentially detailed discussions.

Understand Who is Calling and Their Purpose

It’s crucial to determine which insurance company is contacting you and why. Insurance policies are varied, and your loved one may have had multiple policies for different purposes:

Life Insurance Policies

Life insurance aims to provide financial security for beneficiaries after a death. If this is the nature of the call, it’s likely that they are reaching out regarding claim filing processes, documentation requirements, and beneficiary information.

Auto Insurance or Liability Policies

In cases involving a car accident or other form of liability claim, the insurance company may be contacting you about the settlement or other responsibilities.

Health or Medical Insurance

Medical expenses incurred in the final days of your loved one’s life may need to be reconciled, and health insurance providers may seek to discuss coverage of these costs.

Ask for the caller’s name, their position, the specific insurance company, and the type of policy they’re calling about. This information can help you better understand the context of their call and decide how best to proceed.

Leland Malchow

Attorney - Partner

Chris Johnson

Attorney - Partner

Dane Anderson

Associate Attorney

Avoid Giving Detailed Statements or Agreeing to Anything Right Away

Insurance companies, while professional, are looking out for their financial interests. They may subtly encourage you to provide details about your loved one’s death, finances, or the nature of potential claims. Avoid giving any detailed statements or agreeing to any settlements without thoroughly reviewing the situation. Instead, thank them for the information, ask any questions you have, and let them know you’ll get back to them once you’ve had a chance to process and prepare.

It is also worth mentioning that insurance representatives are trained to ask questions that may seem harmless but could later be used to reduce or deny your claim. Keeping details to a minimum protects you from inadvertently weakening your case or your loved one’s intended benefits.

Request Written Communication

One of the most effective ways to ensure clarity and transparency is to request all communication in writing. Politely ask the insurance company to email or mail any information regarding policies, claims, or other important documentation. Having a written record can be beneficial in several ways:

Review at Your Own Pace

Written information allows you to review complex terms and conditions without the pressure of a phone conversation.

Documentation for Future Reference

Keeping these records ensures you have a clear timeline and factual record of communications, which can be helpful if any disputes or misunderstandings arise later.

Professional Assistance

Written communications make it easier for you to share details with an attorney if you later decide that legal guidance would be beneficial.

Consult Your Loved One’s Documents for Relevant Policies and Beneficiaries

Before proceeding further, take time to review any available documents your loved one may have kept regarding their insurance policies. Locate and organize the following:

Life Insurance Policy

Review the policy to confirm beneficiaries, coverage amounts, and any particular stipulations or conditions.

Health Insurance Statements

These can provide insight into what medical expenses were covered or any outstanding claims.

Accident or Liability Insurance

Check for any policies covering accidents or liability if the death was accidental or involved another party.

Gathering this information can provide clarity on your loved one’s wishes and intentions and help you understand your role as a potential beneficiary or estate representative.

Related Videos

Contact an Attorney if Needed

Navigating insurance claims can be complex, especially in a time of grief. If you feel uncertain or suspect that the insurance company may be taking advantage of your vulnerable position, consulting an attorney may provide peace of mind. At Nimmons Malchow Johnson Injury Lawyers, we offer compassionate guidance for families in Georgia and South Carolina, helping them navigate these difficult times. An attorney can review the policies, interpret the terms, and advocate for you to ensure your loved one’s intentions are honored.

Some situations where legal counsel may be beneficial include:

Disputed Claims

If the insurance company contests your right to benefits or denies coverage, a lawyer can assess the claim and work on your behalf to resolve any disputes.

Ambiguous Policy Language

Insurance policies often contain complex language and exclusions that may not be immediately clear. A lawyer can clarify any confusing terms and conditions.

Delayed or Partial Payouts

If you feel that the insurance company is stalling or offering less than the policy’s stated value, an attorney can investigate the reasons and help secure a fair resolution.

Carefully Review the Claim Process and Gather Necessary Documents

Once you’re ready to file a claim, the insurance company will likely require specific documents to process it. Commonly requested documents include:

Death Certificate

Most insurance claims require a certified copy of the death certificate, which serves as official proof of death.

Policy Documentation

Providing a copy of the policy (if available) can expedite the process and help ensure you receive the full benefit amount.

Proof of Relationship or Beneficiary Status

In cases where multiple beneficiaries are named, you may need to provide proof of your relationship to the deceased.

It’s advisable to create a checklist of all required documentation, keeping track of each item to streamline the claims process. Taking the time to review these documents thoroughly can prevent delays and misunderstandings.

Client Testimonials

Handle Settlement Offers with Caution

In some cases, the insurance company may propose a settlement or offer an expedited payout. While this can be tempting during a time of emotional and financial strain, it’s wise to consider these offers carefully. Some settlement offers may include terms that reduce the payout or release the insurance company from future claims. Before accepting any offer, make sure you fully understand the implications.

An attorney can help you review any settlement offers, evaluate if they’re fair, and advise you on whether to negotiate for a higher amount. This can provide you with the reassurance that you’re making decisions that align with your loved one’s intentions and your family’s best interests.

Consider Financial and Tax Implications

Receiving a life insurance payout or settlement can have financial and tax implications that may not be immediately obvious. While many life insurance benefits are tax-free, other forms of compensation may not be. If you have questions about managing these funds, it might be beneficial to speak with a financial advisor or tax professional who can provide guidance based on your specific situation.

Take Time to Reflect and Move Forward

The process of settling insurance matters after the death of a loved one can be emotionally exhausting. It’s okay to take the time you need, even if it means pausing the process periodically to care for yourself and your family. Grieving is a journey, and no legal matter should prevent you from processing your emotions and honoring your loved one in your way.

If you’re in Georgia or South Carolina and need further assistance or simply someone to talk to about your situation, remember that the team at Nimmons Malchow Johnson Injury Lawyers is here for you. We understand the emotional challenges and practical difficulties of navigating insurance matters after a loss. Our goal is to provide the guidance and support you need to ensure that your loved one’s legacy is preserved and that their final wishes are respected.

If you have questions or need guidance on a call from an insurance company, feel free to reach out.